Large-scale retrenchments after the Constitutional Court’s Industrial Oleo judgment

When a large employer restructures, the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 (LRA) imposes a special process. Section 189A applies to large-scale retrenchments and gives employees and unions powerful options, including the right to strike over the reasons for the retrenchment or to challenge its fairness in the Labour Court.

In 2026, the Constitutional Court settled a question that had divided the courts for years: after a failed facilitation, must employees go to the CCMA for conciliation before approaching the Labour Court? In National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa and Others v Industrial Oleo Chemical Products [2026] ZACC 22, the majority held that they do not. Employees can refer a substantive fairness dispute directly to the Labour Court.

For large employers, the judgment means that litigation can follow quickly after dismissal notices are issued, and that the facilitation stage carries even more weight. Draft LRA amendments published in February 2026 also propose further changes to the section 189A framework.

When does section 189A apply?

Section 189A applies to employers with more than 50 employees that contemplate dismissing, for operational reasons, at least a threshold number of employees within a 12-month period. The threshold rises with the size of the workforce, from 10 employees for employers with between 51 and 200 employees, up to 50 employees for employers with more than 500. Earlier dismissals in the same 12-month period count towards the threshold, so a series of smaller retrenchments can trigger section 189A.

The ordinary consultation requirements of section 189 still apply, including the written notice under section 189(3) disclosing the reasons, alternatives considered, numbers and categories affected, selection criteria and severance pay. See our article on the section 189 process.

Facilitation and the timeline

Either the employer or the consulting parties representing a majority of affected employees may request the CCMA to appoint a facilitator. Where facilitation takes place, the employer may not give notice of dismissal until at least 60 days after the section 189(3) notice. Where there is no facilitation, the dispute must first go through conciliation, and a 30-day period must expire before the next steps can follow.

Facilitation is often the most important stage of a large retrenchment. The facilitator chairs the meetings, helps the parties manage disclosure and alternatives, and can make rulings on procedural issues. A well-run facilitation can resolve the process by agreement. A poorly prepared one can produce disputes that run for years.

After notice: strike or court

Once the process is complete and notices of dismissal are issued, employees and their unions can choose one of two routes on the substantive fairness of the retrenchment:

  • Industrial action. They may give notice of a strike over the proposed dismissals, following the procedure in section 64.
  • Litigation. They may refer a dispute about whether there was a fair reason for the dismissal to the Labour Court.

Procedural complaints during the process can currently be raised by urgent application to the Labour Court under section 189A(13), which allows the court to compel the employer to comply with a fair procedure or to interdict dismissals until it does.

What the Constitutional Court decided

In the Industrial Oleo case, employees who had been retrenched after a failed facilitation went straight to the Labour Court. The employer objected that they had not first referred the dispute to the CCMA for conciliation. The Labour Court rejected the objection, the Labour Appeal Court upheld it, and the Constitutional Court reversed the Labour Appeal Court.

The majority reasoned that the LRA’s wording allows direct referral to the Labour Court after facilitation, that facilitation and conciliation cover largely the same ground, and that requiring a further conciliation step would undermine the expedited scheme for large-scale retrenchments. A minority judgment disagreed. The matter was sent back to the Labour Court to decide the merits.

The practical consequences for employers are:

  • No conciliation buffer. A jurisdictional objection based only on the absence of conciliation after facilitation is unlikely to succeed.
  • Litigation can follow quickly. Employers should expect a Labour Court referral within the 90-day referral period after notices are received.
  • The record of facilitation is your evidence. The Labour Court will look closely at what was disclosed, what alternatives were considered and how selection criteria were applied.

Proposed changes on the horizon

The Labour Relations Amendment Bill published for comment in February 2026 proposes, among other things, that the CCMA rather than the Minister make the facilitation rules, that facilitators may set picketing rules, that procedural fairness challenges be dealt with as disputes after dismissal rather than by urgent applications during the process, and that the LRA state expressly that conciliation is not required after facilitation. A separate draft amendment to the Basic Conditions of Employment Act 75 of 1997 proposes increasing statutory severance pay from one to two weeks’ remuneration per completed year of service, for service after the amendment takes effect. These remain proposals until enacted.

A checklist for large-scale retrenchments

  1. Calculate whether the section 189A thresholds are met, including earlier dismissals in the past 12 months.
  2. Prepare the business case and financial information before issuing the section 189(3) notice.
  3. Draft the notice carefully. It will be scrutinised by the facilitator, the unions and possibly the court.
  4. Decide whether to request facilitation, and prepare for it as you would for a hearing.
  5. Consider alternatives seriously and record why each was accepted or rejected.
  6. Agree or justify objective selection criteria, and apply them consistently.
  7. Plan for a possible strike, including contingency operations and picketing rules.
  8. Keep a complete record of meetings, disclosures and responses.
  9. Prepare for a Labour Court referral soon after notices are issued.

How O’Reilly Law can help

We advise employers on restructuring and large-scale retrenchments from the planning stage, draft section 189(3) notices, represent employers in CCMA facilitation, advise on strike contingency and picketing, and defend procedural and substantive fairness challenges in the Labour Court.

Contact us before you issue a section 189(3) notice.

Related reading: Retrenchments: getting the section 189 process right · High-stakes commercial litigation: a strategy guide

This article is general information and not legal advice. Correct as at November 2026.