Labour brokers, contractors and deemed employment: reviewing your contingent workforce

Large employers rarely rely only on their own employees. Labour brokers, outsourced service providers, independent contractors and, increasingly, platform-based workers all form part of the modern workforce. These arrangements offer flexibility, but South African labour law looks past labels to the reality of the relationship, and the consequences of getting it wrong can include deemed employment, joint liability and claims for equal treatment.

The rules are also moving. In January 2026, the Minister of Employment and Labour gave notice of an intention to deem performers in advertising, artistic and cultural activities to be employees for the purposes of key labour statutes. In February 2026, a draft Labour Relations Amendment Bill proposed extending collective rights to certain “dependent contractors”, with a presumption in their favour. This article explains the current framework and what large employers should review.

Labour brokers: temporary employment services

Under section 198 of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 (LRA), a temporary employment service (TES) that procures workers for a client and pays them is their employer. The client and the TES are, however, jointly and severally liable for certain contraventions, including of collective agreements, arbitration awards and the Basic Conditions of Employment Act 75 of 1997.

Section 198A adds important protection for TES employees who earn below the earnings threshold, which was increased to R269,600.90 a year from 1 May 2026:

  • A TES may only place such employees to perform a temporary service, broadly work for not more than three months, as a substitute for a temporarily absent employee, or in a category of work designated as temporary.
  • If the placement goes beyond a temporary service, the employee is deemed to be the employee of the client and employed indefinitely, unless there is a justifiable reason for fixing the term.
  • Once deemed, the employee must be treated on the whole not less favourably than the client’s employees doing the same or similar work, unless there is a justifiable reason for the difference.

In 2018, in Assign Services (Pty) Ltd v National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa, the Constitutional Court confirmed that once the deeming provision applies, the client becomes the sole employer of the placed employee for the purposes of the LRA. Under the Employment Equity Act 55 of 1998, employees placed by a TES for more than three months are also treated as the client’s employees for employment equity purposes.

Independent contractors

Calling someone an independent contractor does not make them one. Section 200A of the LRA presumes that a person earning below the threshold is an employee if any one of a list of factors is present, for example that their hours or manner of work are controlled by another person, they form part of the organisation, they have worked for that person for an average of at least 40 hours a month over the last three months, they are economically dependent on that person, or the tools of trade are provided by that person. The employer must then prove otherwise. The Code of Good Practice: Who is an Employee guides how the presumption and the broader test are applied, even above the threshold.

Misclassification can lead to claims for unfair dismissal, leave, overtime and other benefits, as well as tax, UIF and compensation fund consequences.

What is changing

Dependent contractors

The February 2026 draft Labour Relations Amendment Bill proposes a new schedule extending freedom of association, organisational rights and collective bargaining rights to dependent contractors, such as some gig and platform workers. A worker would be presumed to be covered unless the business shows that the worker is not controlled by it, does not form part of its organisation, and does not deal with its clients on its terms. Comment closed on 28 March 2026. The proposal could significantly affect platform businesses and large users of individual contractors.

Performers in advertising and the arts

On 23 January 2026, the Minister published a notice of intention to deem performers in advertising, artistic and cultural activities to be employees for specified purposes, including working time, leave, written particulars, pay and severance pay under the Basic Conditions of Employment Act, the National Minimum Wage Act 9 of 2018, the Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Diseases Act 130 of 1993 and a provision of the LRA on long fixed-term contracts. Brands, agencies and production companies that engage performers should follow this closely.

Questions to ask about your contingent workforce

  • How many workers are placed by labour brokers, at what earnings levels and for how long?
  • Are placements genuinely temporary, or are TES employees doing permanent work alongside your own staff?
  • Are deemed employees being treated on the whole not less favourably than comparable employees?
  • Do your contractors work like employees, under your control, at your premises, with your tools, for you alone?
  • Do your outsourcing agreements contain warranties, audit rights and indemnities covering labour law compliance?
  • Have you considered the impact of these workers on your employment equity plan and reporting?

A compliance checklist

  1. Map all TES placements, outsourced services and individual contractors across the group.
  2. Identify placements that exceed three months or do not qualify as a temporary service.
  3. Compare terms and conditions of deemed employees with those of comparable employees.
  4. Test individual contractor arrangements against section 200A and the Code.
  5. Review and update TES and service agreements, including liability allocation.
  6. Align procurement and HR so that new arrangements are vetted before they start.
  7. Monitor the dependent contractor proposals and the performer deeming notice.

How O’Reilly Law can help

We audit contingent workforce arrangements, advise on section 198A deeming and equal treatment, review and draft TES, outsourcing and contractor agreements, and represent employers in disputes about employment status and deemed employment.

Contact us to review your labour broker and contractor arrangements.

Related reading: Fixed-term contracts: when a temporary employee becomes permanent · Employment equity targets: what employers must do

This article is general information and not legal advice. Correct as at November 2026.