Franchising, licensing or distribution? Choosing your growth model

When a business works, the next question is how to grow it beyond what the founders can run themselves. Three models come up again and again: franchising, licensing and distribution. Each lets other people use your brand or sell your products, but each gives you a different level of control, a different income stream and a different set of legal duties.

The choice matters more now than it did a year ago. In July 2026 the Competition Commission published draft terms of reference for a market inquiry into the franchise sector, citing concerns about pricing, supplier rebates, financial projections and the balance of power between franchisors and franchisees. Businesses that call their model “franchising” should expect more scrutiny. Those that use a licence or distribution model need to be sure it is not a franchise in disguise.

This article compares the three models and the law that applies to each.

Franchising: a full business system

A franchise gives the franchisee the right to run a business under your brand, using your system, in return for fees. The Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008 (CPA) defines a franchise agreement broadly. In summary, an arrangement is likely to be a franchise if:

  • the franchisee pays a fee or other consideration;
  • the franchisee uses your name, trade mark or business system;
  • you prescribe or significantly control how the business is run; and
  • you provide support or assistance, such as training, marketing or operations manuals.

If the CPA definition is met, the franchisee is treated as a consumer for many purposes, and specific rules apply:

  • the agreement must be in writing, signed by the franchisee, and contain the information prescribed by the CPA regulations;
  • the franchisor must give a prospective franchisee a disclosure document at least 14 days before signing, including financial information and details of other franchisees;
  • the franchisee may cancel without cost or penalty by written notice within 10 business days after signing; and
  • the regulations prohibit certain unfair terms and require clear provisions on matters such as fees, termination and the franchisee’s rights on exit.

Best suited to: businesses with a proven, documented system that can be replicated, and a franchisor with the capacity to train, support and monitor a network. Franchising gives the most control and usually the highest ongoing income, but also the heaviest compliance load. See our article on franchise disputes and termination.

Licensing: using your intellectual property

A licence gives someone the right to use your intellectual property, such as a trade mark, design, software, recipe or content, usually in return for a royalty. A pure licence does not involve you controlling how the licensee runs its business.

Licensing works well where your value lies in the IP itself: a brand on merchandise, a patented process, or software. You keep ownership of the IP and earn income without running operations. The key legal points are:

  • Protect the IP first. Register your trade marks under the Trade Marks Act 194 of 1993 and, where relevant, your designs or patents. You cannot license what you do not clearly own.
  • Quality control. Trade mark licences should contain quality standards, so that use by the licensee supports your rights rather than weakening them.
  • Royalties and reporting. Set out the royalty base, rates, minimum payments, audit rights and reporting periods.
  • Cross-border royalties. Where a South African licensee pays royalties to a non-resident, exchange control approval may be required and withholding tax on royalties will usually apply, subject to any double tax agreement.

The trap is drift. If your “licence” starts to include an operating manual, mandatory suppliers, required training and ongoing support, it may meet the CPA definition of a franchise, with the disclosure and cooling-off obligations that follow.

Distribution: selling your products

A distributor buys your products and resells them, usually in a defined territory or channel. The distributor makes its money on the margin, not by paying you fees for a business system. Distribution suits manufacturers and brand owners who want reach without opening their own outlets.

Key legal issues include exclusivity, minimum purchase targets, pricing, stock, returns, product liability and termination. The Competition Act 89 of 1998 is particularly important here:

  • Minimum resale price maintenance is prohibited. You may recommend a resale price, but you may not force a distributor to sell at or above a minimum price.
  • Exclusive territories and non-compete clauses can be lawful, but they should be justified and proportionate, especially where either party has significant market power.

Our article on distribution and supply agreements covers the main contract terms.

Comparing the three models

  • Control: high in franchising, limited to IP use and quality in licensing, and mostly commercial (targets, territory) in distribution.
  • Income: upfront and ongoing fees in franchising; royalties in licensing; product margins in distribution.
  • Your investment: substantial for franchising (system, training, support); low to moderate for licensing; moderate for distribution (supply chain, marketing support).
  • Regulation: heaviest for franchising (CPA disclosure, cooling-off, regulations); IP and tax rules for licensing; competition law and product liability for distribution.
  • Brand risk: managed through the system in franchising; through quality control in licensing; through product standards and channel rules in distribution.

Choosing your model: practical steps

  1. Identify what creates your value. Is it the system, the brand and IP, or the product itself?
  2. Decide how much control you need. If customer experience depends on detailed operating standards, you are probably looking at franchising.
  3. Assess your capacity. Franchising requires training, field support and ongoing monitoring. Be realistic about resources.
  4. Protect your IP. Register trade marks and document know-how before you share it.
  5. Test the CPA definition. If your proposed licence or distribution model includes fees, control and support, get advice on whether it is a franchise.
  6. Check competition law. Review pricing, exclusivity and supplier arrangements, especially given the Commission’s current focus on franchising.
  7. Consider tax and exchange control. Particularly for cross-border royalties and fees.
  8. Put it in writing. Each model needs a tailored agreement, not a template borrowed from a different model.

How O’Reilly Law can help

We advise brand owners on choosing and structuring a growth model, and we draft and review franchise agreements, disclosure documents, operations manual provisions, IP licence agreements and distribution agreements. We also advise on CPA franchise compliance, competition law risks in pricing and exclusivity, and the protection of trade marks and know-how before expansion.

Contact us to discuss the right growth model for your business.

Related reading: Master franchise agreements: expanding into Africa · Distribution and supply agreements: key terms

This article is general information and not legal or tax advice. Correct as at November 2026.