When a construction project goes wrong, the construction guarantee is often the first thing an employer reaches for and the first thing a contractor tries to protect. Whether a call on the guarantee succeeds depends mostly on one question: what kind of guarantee is it?
This article explains the two main types of construction guarantee, when an employer can call one up, and the very limited circumstances in which a contractor can stop payment.
Why construction guarantees exist
Most building contracts require the contractor to provide security for its performance, usually a guarantee issued by a bank or insurer in favour of the employer. Common types include:
- performance guarantees, securing the contractor’s obligation to complete the works properly;
- advance payment guarantees, securing repayment of any upfront payment the employer makes;
- retention guarantees, given in place of cash retention deducted from payment certificates.
The guarantee is a separate contract between the guarantor (the bank or insurer) and the beneficiary (usually the employer). The contractor is not a party to it, although it arranged and pays for it.
On-demand vs accessory guarantees
The wording of the guarantee determines how it behaves.
| On-demand (independent) guarantee | Accessory (conditional) guarantee | |
| What triggers payment | A written demand that complies with the guarantee’s terms | Proof that the contractor is actually liable to the employer |
| Role of the building contract | Largely irrelevant to the guarantor’s duty to pay | Central: the guarantor’s liability follows the contractor’s |
| Legal character | Similar to a letter of credit | Similar to a suretyship |
| Speed of payout | Fast: pay first, argue later | Slow: liability must usually be established first |
The distinction matters. In Basil Read (Pty) Ltd v Beta Hotels (Pty) Ltd 2001 (2) SA 760 (C), the court found that the guarantee in the 1991 JBCC form was in the nature of a suretyship. The guarantor was liable only if, and to the extent that, the contractor was liable. Modern guarantees, especially on larger and public projects, are far more often drafted as on-demand instruments.
Calling up an on-demand guarantee
The Supreme Court of Appeal settled the approach to on-demand construction guarantees in 2013 and 2014.
In Guardrisk Insurance Company Ltd v Kentz (Pty) Ltd [2014] 1 All SA 307 (SCA), the court likened a construction guarantee to a letter of credit. The guarantor’s obligation is independent of the underlying building contract: once a demand meets the guarantee’s conditions, the guarantor must pay. In Coface South Africa Insurance Co Ltd v East London Own Haven 2014 (2) SA 382 (SCA), the court confirmed that disputes between employer and contractor over whether there really was a breach do not affect the guarantor’s duty to pay on demand.
The reason is commercial: the purpose of the guarantee is to give the employer cash immediately, without waiting for the underlying dispute to be resolved. Any overpayment is sorted out later, between employer and contractor, under the building contract.
For employers, this means:
- read the guarantee, not just the building contract, and comply strictly with its demand requirements (form, signatory, wording, expiry date and address for presentation);
- make the demand before the guarantee expires; a late demand generally fails;
- only call where you genuinely believe you are entitled. A call made knowing there is no entitlement can be interdicted and may expose you to a damages claim.
Can a contractor stop the call?
Only in narrow circumstances. Since a call on an on-demand guarantee is independent of the building contract, a contractor cannot stop payment simply because it disputes the employer’s claim.
The fraud exception. The established ground is fraud. Where the employer makes a demand knowing that it is not entitled to payment, a court may interdict the guarantor from paying. The bar is high: the contractor must clearly establish the employer’s dishonesty, not just show that the employer is probably wrong. A genuine but mistaken belief in a claim is not fraud.
A possible second route, before the call is made. In Joint Venture between Aveng (Africa) (Pty) Ltd and Strabag International GmbH v SANRAL (SCA, November 2020), the court emphasised the autonomy of on-demand guarantees but recognised that there may be room, in principle, to restrain an employer from calling a guarantee where the building contract itself prohibits the call. It referred to English and Australian law, where this route is established. This avenue remains narrow and largely untested in South Africa, so contractors should not rely on it without careful advice.
Practical steps for contractors facing a threatened call:
- Get the guarantee and the building contract in front of your lawyer immediately. Time is usually very short.
- Check whether the demand complies strictly with the guarantee’s terms. A non-compliant demand can be rejected by the guarantor.
- Assess whether there is objective evidence that the employer knows it has no entitlement, which is the foundation of a fraud-based interdict.
- If the call succeeds, preserve your claim to recover the money under the building contract, usually through adjudication or arbitration.
Getting it right at the drafting stage
Most guarantee disputes are decided by the wording agreed at the start. Contractors should push for clear limits on when a call may be made, and employers should make sure the instrument is genuinely on-demand if that is what they are paying for. Both sides benefit from a contract review before the guarantee is issued.
How O’Reilly Law can help
We advise employers on making valid guarantee calls, and act for contractors seeking urgent interdicts or recovering amounts paid out. Contact our litigation and dispute resolution team as soon as a call is threatened; these matters move in days, not weeks.
Related reading: Construction adjudication in South Africa · Construction delays and penalties
Contact us to discuss your matter.
This article is general information and not legal advice. The outcome of any dispute depends on the wording of the guarantee, the contract and the facts. Correct as at October 2026.