Construction delays, extensions of time and penalties

Almost every construction project in South Africa runs late to some degree. Whether that delay costs the contractor penalties, or entitles it to more time and money, depends on two things: what caused the delay, and whether the right notices were given at the right time.

This article explains how extensions of time and delay penalties work under South African building contracts, and how the Conventional Penalties Act limits what an employer can recover.

The basic framework

Standard-form contracts such as the JBCC Principal Building Agreement, NEC, FIDIC and GCC all follow the same broad logic:

  • the contractor must reach practical completion (or its equivalent) by the agreed date;
  • if it is late for reasons it is responsible for, it pays a penalty, usually a fixed amount per calendar day;
  • if it is delayed by events the employer carries the risk for, such as late information, variations, or certain weather and site conditions, it may claim an extension of time and, often, additional costs.

An extension of time moves the completion date. That protects the contractor from penalties for the extended period. Whether it also comes with money depends on the cause of the delay and the contract wording.

Extensions of time: notice is everything

The most common reason contractors lose valid delay claims is procedural. Most standard forms require the contractor to give written notice of a delaying event within a fixed period, followed by a substantiated claim. Some contracts treat a missed deadline as a complete bar to the claim.

For contractors:

  1. Give notice as soon as a potential delay arises, even if the full impact is not yet known.
  2. Keep a current programme and update it regularly. Delay claims are proved through the programme and the critical path.
  3. Record the cause, start date and effect of each delaying event in site minutes, correspondence and daily diaries.
  4. Submit the detailed claim within the contractual time limit, and follow up if no decision is made.

For employers and their agents:

  • assess extension claims fairly and within the contractual timeframe;
  • give reasons for rejecting or reducing a claim;
  • remember that refusing a valid extension does not make the delay the contractor’s fault. It usually just creates a dispute about the penalties you later deduct.

How delay penalties work in South Africa

South African law draws no meaningful distinction between “liquidated damages” and “penalties” when it comes to enforceability. The Conventional Penalties Act 15 of 1962 makes penalty stipulations enforceable, and a penalty does not need to be a genuine pre-estimate of the employer’s loss to be valid.

The Act does impose important limits:

  • No double recovery (section 2(1)). An employer cannot recover both the penalty and damages for the same delay. It can only claim damages instead of the penalty if the contract expressly allows it.
  • Accepting late performance (section 2(2)). An employer who accepts late completion can only claim a penalty for that delay if the penalty was expressly stipulated for delay. Standard construction penalty clauses usually are.
  • Reduction of excessive penalties (section 3). If a penalty is out of proportion to the prejudice the employer suffered, a court may reduce it to what is equitable. In assessing prejudice, the court considers not only financial loss but every other rightful interest affected.

The onus to show that a penalty is excessive rests on the party that has to pay it, usually the contractor. The Supreme Court of Appeal confirmed in 2006 that the creditor need not allege or prove prejudice to claim the penalty. In practice, a contractor seeking a reduction needs evidence of what the delay actually cost the employer.

Can penalties be deducted while the dispute is ongoing?

Often, yes. In Basil Read (Pty) Ltd v Beta Hotels (Pty) Ltd 2001 (2) SA 760 (C), the court held that under the JBCC form in issue, the contractor’s liability for penalties was not suspended while the dispute went to arbitration. Employers commonly deduct penalties from payment certificates as they accrue.

The deduction must still follow the contract. Most forms require a written notice before penalties are deducted, and a deduction made without it can be challenged, often through adjudication.

Concurrent delay and “time at large”

Two arguments regularly appear in larger delay disputes:

  • Concurrent delay, where the employer and contractor both cause delay over the same period. Contracts increasingly say how this is to be handled. Where they are silent, the outcome is uncertain and turns heavily on expert programme analysis.
  • Time at large, the argument that where the employer has caused delay and the contract has no mechanism to extend time for it, the completion date falls away and the employer loses its right to penalties. South African case law on this point is limited, and modern standard forms try to avoid it with broad extension provisions.

Both arguments are fact-heavy and expensive to run. They are best assessed early, with a delay expert, before positions harden.

How O’Reilly Law can help

We advise contractors on preparing and pursuing extension and delay claims, and advise employers on assessing claims and deducting penalties defensibly. Our litigation and dispute resolution team handles delay disputes through adjudication, arbitration and court, and our commercial contracts practice helps set realistic penalty and notice provisions before work starts.

Related reading: Unpaid payment certificates · Construction guarantees

Contact us to discuss your matter.

This article is general information and not legal advice. The outcome of any dispute depends on the wording of the contract and the facts. Correct as at October 2026.