Practical completion is a milestone, not the end of a contractor’s responsibility. Cracks, leaks and failing finishes often appear months or years after handover, and the question then is who must fix them, who pays, and whether the claim is still in time.
This article explains how South African building contracts deal with defects after completion, the remedies available to employers, and the protections and limits that apply to contractors.
Patent and latent defects
The law and the standard-form contracts distinguish between two kinds of defect:
- Patent defects are visible on a reasonable inspection at handover. They are usually listed on the snag list (the JBCC calls it the list for completion) and must be fixed before final completion.
- Latent defects are hidden and only become apparent later, such as inadequate waterproofing, poor compaction or reinforcement that does not match the drawings.
The distinction matters because different contractual periods, and different time limits, apply to each.
The three contractual stages
Most South African building contracts, including the JBCC Principal Building Agreement, divide the post-construction period into three stages:
- Practical completion. The works can be used for their intended purpose, free of patent defects other than minor items on the list for completion. The employer usually takes occupation and part of the retention may be released.
- Defects liability period. A fixed period after practical completion, often 90 days to 12 months depending on the contract data, during which the contractor must return to fix defects notified by the employer. Final completion is certified once those defects have been remedied.
- Latent defects liability period. A longer period during which the contractor remains liable for latent defects. Under the JBCC it typically runs for five years from final completion, but the contract data and any amendments must always be checked.
NEC and FIDIC use different terms (defects date, defects notification period) but the logic is similar. In every case, the specific wording of your contract governs.
Remedies for employers
If a defect appears, the employer’s main options are:
- Require the contractor to return and remedy it. Give written notice identifying the defect and a reasonable period for repair, as the contract requires.
- Use another contractor and recover the cost. If the contractor fails to remedy a notified defect, most contracts allow the employer to have the work done by others and recover the cost, often by deduction from amounts still due.
- Draw on retention or security. Retention money and retention guarantees exist partly for this purpose. See our guide to calling up construction guarantees.
- Claim damages. Where the defect causes further loss, such as business interruption or damage to other property, the employer may claim damages for breach of contract, subject to any limitation of liability clause.
The employer’s professional team may also be relevant. Where a defect stems from design or supervision rather than workmanship, the architect or engineer may be the correct party to claim against.
Protections for contractors
Contractors are not liable for every problem that emerges after handover. Common defences include:
- The defect was caused by design, not workmanship. A contractor that built to the drawings and specification is generally not responsible for a design fault, unless it took on design responsibility.
- The damage results from use or maintenance. Wear and tear, misuse and poor maintenance by the employer are not defects.
- The claim was not notified properly. Most contracts require written notice. A contractor not given the chance to remedy a defect may have a defence to the cost of having others fix it.
- The claim is out of time. See the next section.
Contractors should respond to every defect notice in writing, inspect promptly and record their position, even if they dispute liability.
Time limits: prescription and statutory warranties
Prescription. Under the Prescription Act 68 of 1969, a contractual claim generally prescribes three years after the debt becomes due. For latent defects, prescription only starts running once the employer knows, or reasonably should have known, the facts giving rise to the claim. That can extend the window, but employers should not assume it will: act as soon as a defect is identified.
New homes. For residential work by a registered home builder, the Housing Consumers Protection Measures Act 95 of 1998 adds statutory warranties enforced through the National Home Builders Registration Council (NHBRC). These include a five-year warranty against major structural defects and shorter periods for roof leaks and non-compliance with plans. These warranties sit alongside, not instead of, the building contract.
Practical guidance
For employers: inspect carefully at practical completion and record everything on the list for completion; diarise the end of the defects liability period and do a full inspection before it closes; notify defects in writing as they arise; and keep photographs and expert reports.
For contractors: keep as-built records and test certificates, document handover condition, and track every defect notice and response. Clear records are usually the difference between a defensible position and an expensive settlement.
How O’Reilly Law can help
We act for employers and developers pursuing defect claims, and for contractors defending them, from early correspondence through to adjudication, arbitration or court. Speak to our litigation and dispute resolution team, or ask our commercial contracts practice to review your defects and retention provisions before the next project.
Related reading: Unpaid payment certificates · Construction delays and penalties
Contact us to discuss your matter.
This article is general information and not legal advice. The outcome of any dispute depends on the wording of the contract and the facts. Correct as at October 2026.