Construction adjudication in South Africa: why the decision must be paid now

If you have received an adjudicator’s decision on a construction project, the short answer is this: comply now, argue later. South African courts consistently enforce adjudicators’ decisions, even where the losing party has formally recorded its dissatisfaction and intends to go to arbitration.

This article explains how adjudication works, why courts treat the decision as binding, and the narrow circumstances in which a decision can be resisted.

What is construction adjudication?

Adjudication is a fast, interim dispute resolution process built into most standard-form construction contracts used in South Africa, including the JBCC Principal Building Agreement, the NEC suite and FIDIC. An independent adjudicator, usually a construction professional or senior lawyer, decides the dispute within a short contractual timeframe.

The purpose is cash flow. Construction disputes over payment, variations or extensions of time can take years to resolve in arbitration or court. Adjudication gives the parties a decision in weeks, so the project and the money keep moving while the final position is worked out.

Unlike the United Kingdom, South Africa has no statute that gives every construction party a right to adjudicate. Draft prompt payment and adjudication regulations were proposed by the Construction Industry Development Board (CIDB) but have not been brought into force. In South Africa, adjudication is therefore a creature of contract: your rights depend on the wording of the agreement you signed.

How the process typically works

The detail varies between contracts and editions, but most adjudication clauses follow a similar pattern:

  1. A disagreement arises and is not resolved through the contract’s notice and negotiation steps.
  2. One party refers the dispute to an adjudicator, either one named in the contract data or one appointed by a nominating body.
  3. The parties exchange written submissions within strict time limits. The adjudicator often has inquisitorial powers and may decide without a hearing.
  4. The adjudicator delivers a written decision.
  5. The decision is immediately binding and must be implemented. A dissatisfied party may give notice of dissatisfaction within the contractual period (under the JBCC, this is ten working days) and refer the dispute to arbitration.
  6. If no notice is given in time, the decision usually becomes final.

Time limits are critical at every stage. A party that misses the window to give notice of dissatisfaction may lose the right to challenge the decision at all.

Why courts enforce the decision immediately

The leading theme in South African case law is that an adjudicator’s decision is “pay now, argue later”. The decision is not final, but the obligation to comply with it is.

As early as 2013, the Johannesburg High Court held in Stefanutti Stocks (Pty) Ltd v S8 Property (Pty) Ltd that a JBCC adjudicator’s decision is binding and must be implemented immediately, even if arbitration may later revise the parties’ accounts. The same principle emerged from the Esor line of judgments: the decision itself may be overturned, but the duty to pay what it orders is not suspended in the meantime.

The Supreme Court of Appeal has since confirmed this approach twice:

  • In Ekurhuleni West College v Segal and Another [2020] ZASCA 32, an employer tried to have an adjudicator’s determination reviewed and set aside. The SCA dismissed the appeal. It held that the employer had agreed to be bound by the determination, and that the proper route to challenge it was the arbitration the contract provided for.
  • In Framatome v Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd [2021] ZASCA 132, arising from an NEC3 contract at Koeberg, the SCA ordered Eskom to implement an adjudicator’s decision. Eskom’s dissatisfaction did not entitle it to withhold payment. The decision stood until revised by the tribunal the contract named.

Most recently, in Pro-Khaya Construction CC v City of Cape Town (Western Cape High Court, August 2025), the court enforced a JBCC adjudicator’s determination against the City and dismissed its counter-application to review it. The court confirmed that a JBCC adjudicator acts as an expert, not an arbitrator, and that courts will not revisit the merits of the decision.

When can a decision be resisted?

The grounds are narrow. Courts have indicated they may decline to enforce a decision where:

  • The adjudicator clearly lacked jurisdiction. For example, the adjudicator decided a dispute that was never referred, or one the contract excludes. This is not a review; the court simply refuses to enforce a decision that is a nullity. If jurisdiction is merely arguable, the decision is enforced in the interim.
  • The process was fundamentally unfair. A serious breach of the contractual procedure may be relevant, but courts look first at what the parties agreed. In Segal, complaints of procedural unfairness failed because the adjudicator followed the agreed rules.
  • There is fraud or a manifestly unjust outcome. These are exceptional and difficult to prove.

An error of fact or law by the adjudicator is not, on its own, a reason to refuse enforcement. That is what arbitration is for.

It also matters when you raise an objection. In Framatome, the SCA noted that Eskom had not challenged the adjudicator’s jurisdiction during the adjudication itself. A party that participates without objecting will struggle to raise jurisdiction for the first time in court.

Practical guidance

If you are referring a dispute (often the contractor or subcontractor):

  • Follow the contract’s notice provisions exactly before referring. A defective referral invites a jurisdiction challenge.
  • Define the dispute clearly in the referral, so the decision cannot be said to go beyond it.
  • If the other side does not pay, move promptly for an enforcement order in the High Court. Courts generally deal with these applications on motion.

If you are responding (often the employer or main contractor):

  • Raise any jurisdiction objection at the start of the adjudication, in writing, and reserve your rights.
  • Diarise the notice-of-dissatisfaction deadline the day the decision arrives.
  • Budget to comply. Withholding payment while you pursue arbitration usually leads to an enforcement application and a costs order against you.

How O’Reilly Law can help

We act for contractors, subcontractors, developers and employers in construction disputes, from preparing or responding to adjudication referrals to enforcement applications and arbitration. Our litigation and dispute resolution team can assess your position quickly, and our commercial contracts practice can review your dispute clauses before the next project starts.

Related reading: Unpaid payment certificates · Construction delays and penalties

Contact us to discuss your matter.

This article is general information and not legal advice. The outcome of any dispute depends on the wording of the contract and the facts. Correct as at October 2026.