Usufructs and fideicommissa in wills: leaving property for life, then to the next generation

Many people want to provide for two generations with one asset. A common example is the family home: you want your surviving spouse to live there for the rest of their life, but you want the property itself to end up with your children, not with a new partner or someone else’s family. Farms, holiday homes and investment properties raise the same question.

South African law offers two traditional tools for this in a will: the usufruct and the fideicommissum. Both give one person the benefit of property for a period and then pass it on to someone else. But they work differently, they have different tax effects, and a poorly worded will can leave heirs arguing over which one the testator intended.

This article explains both, how they compare with a testamentary trust, and what to think about before using them.

The usufruct

A usufruct is a personal servitude. It gives the usufructuary the right to use property and to take its fruits, such as rental income, for a period, usually their lifetime. Ownership goes to other heirs, known as the bare dominium holders, whose rights vest immediately but who only enjoy the property fully once the usufruct ends.

Key features:

  • The usufructuary must look after the property, use it reasonably and keep its substance intact. They generally bear ordinary running costs such as rates and routine maintenance.
  • The usufructuary cannot sell the property, because they do not own it.
  • The bare dominium holders own the property, but cannot sell it free of the usufruct without the usufructuary’s cooperation.
  • For immovable property, the usufruct is registered against the title deed in the Deeds Office, which protects it against later owners.
  • The usufruct ends on the usufructuary’s death, or earlier if the will says so, and the bare dominium holders then hold full ownership.

A lesser alternative is a right of habitation, which allows a person to live in a home without the wider rights of a usufruct. It can suit a situation where you only want to secure accommodation.

The fideicommissum

A fideicommissum works differently. The first heir, called the fiduciary, becomes the owner of the property, but subject to an obligation to pass it on to a second heir, the fideicommissary, when a stated event occurs, usually the fiduciary’s death.

The difference from a usufruct is important:

  • The fiduciary is the owner, not merely a user. The fideicommissary’s right is conditional, and only vests when the condition is fulfilled.
  • If the fideicommissary dies first, the fiduciary may end up with unrestricted ownership, depending on how the will is drafted.
  • Restrictions on selling or burdening the property flow from the fideicommissum itself and are endorsed on the title deed.

The law limits how long a fideicommissum can tie up land. Under the Immovable Property (Removal or Modification of Restrictions) Act 94 of 1965, a fideicommissum over immovable property is limited to two successive fideicommissaries, whatever the will says. There is also a variant, the fideicommissum residui, which allows the fiduciary to use or dispose of part of the property during their lifetime, with only the remainder passing on.

Because fideicommissa restrict ownership, courts lean against finding one where the will is unclear. Clear drafting is essential.

Tax considerations

Both tools have estate duty consequences under the Estate Duty Act 45 of 1955, and they need to be modelled before the will is signed.

  • Valuing a usufruct. The Act values a lifetime usufruct by capitalising an annual return on the property, at 12% unless SARS accepts a lower rate, over the usufructuary’s life expectancy. The bare dominium is valued as the difference. This affects how much duty each part of the estate attracts.
  • Surviving spouse. Property, including a usufruct, that passes to a surviving spouse generally qualifies for the spousal deduction in the first estate. The value can, however, be taxed in the surviving spouse’s estate when the usufruct ends on their death.
  • Capital gains tax and transfer costs also need to be considered, including on any later sale of the property.

The interaction of these rules can produce very different results depending on the ages of the heirs, the value of the property and who receives which interest. The structure should be checked with a tax adviser.

Is a testamentary trust better?

In many modern estate plans, a testamentary trust achieves the same goal with more flexibility. The trustees can hold the property for the surviving spouse’s benefit, sell and replace it if circumstances change, and distribute it to the children later. Trusts bring their own costs, administration and tax rules, so they are not automatically the better option. But where heirs are young, relationships are complex, or the property may need to be sold, a trust is often easier to manage than a usufruct or fideicommissum.

Common pitfalls

  • Wording that does not make clear whether a usufruct, a fideicommissum or an outright bequest is intended.
  • Usufructs over property that will need to be sold, such as a home that the surviving spouse will outgrow.
  • Bare dominium holders who disagree with the usufructuary over maintenance, insurance or improvements.
  • No funds to cover rates, maintenance and transfer costs.
  • Joint wills that create a usufruct through massing without the spouses understanding the effect.

Checklist before including a usufruct or fideicommissum in your will

  1. Identify the asset and the people you want to benefit, now and later.
  2. Decide whether a usufruct, right of habitation, fideicommissum or testamentary trust best fits your goals.
  3. Think about whether the property may need to be sold, and who should decide.
  4. Allocate responsibility for rates, insurance and maintenance.
  5. Model the estate duty and capital gains tax effect with your adviser.
  6. Use precise wording and name substitute heirs.
  7. Review the will after a marriage, divorce, birth or death in the family.

How O’Reilly Law can help

We draft wills and estate plans that use usufructs, fideicommissa and testamentary trusts where they fit, and we explain the practical and tax consequences in plain terms. Through O’Reilly Fiduciary, we also assist executors and heirs with administering estates that include these rights, including registration in the Deeds Office and resolving disputes over the meaning of a will.

Contact us to review your will or plan how your property will pass on.

Related reading: Joint wills and massing: what spouses should know · Testamentary trusts: protecting your children’s inheritance

This article is general information and not legal or tax advice. Correct as at November 2026.