When serious allegations are made against a senior manager, the employer must act quickly to protect evidence, other employees and the business, while also running a process that will withstand scrutiny later. The stakes are high. A senior employee is more likely to challenge the outcome, to litigate during the process, and to seek substantial compensation.
Recent developments help employers. The new Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, in force since September 2025, confirms that disciplinary procedures need not be formal or criminal in style, provided the employee can respond properly. In 2026, the Labour Appeal Court twice emphasised that courts should not lightly interfere in disciplinary processes, and that procedural flaws do not turn a substantively fair dismissal into an unfair one. This article explains how to handle precautionary suspensions and disciplinary processes involving senior employees.
Precautionary suspension
Purpose
A precautionary suspension removes an employee from the workplace while allegations are investigated or a disciplinary process is completed. It is not a sanction. It is justified where the employee’s presence could interfere with the investigation, influence witnesses, destroy evidence, or pose a risk to the business or other employees.
Legal requirements
An unfair suspension is an unfair labour practice under section 186(2)(b) of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 (LRA). In a 2019 judgment in a case involving South African Breweries, the Constitutional Court confirmed that a precautionary suspension on full pay does not require the employer to give the employee a hearing first, because it is not disciplinary in nature. The suspension must nevertheless be for a fair reason and must not cause unnecessary prejudice.
In practice, a precautionary suspension should:
- be on full pay and benefits;
- be based on a genuine reason linked to the investigation or risk, which should be recorded;
- be for as short a period as reasonably possible, with the investigation and hearing pursued promptly;
- be communicated in writing, explaining that it is precautionary and setting out any conditions, such as not contacting colleagues or clients about the matter; and
- be reviewed periodically, especially if delays arise.
Lengthy suspensions on full pay are expensive, damaging to reputations and frequently challenged. Employers should consider whether alternatives, such as temporary reassignment or restricted access to systems, would achieve the same purpose.
Investigating allegations against a senior employee
The quality of the investigation usually decides the case. Allegations against senior employees often involve financial irregularities, procurement, conflicts of interest or harassment, and may require forensic accountants, IT specialists or external investigators.
- Independence. The investigator should be independent of the people involved, particularly if the allegations concern the senior employee’s reporting line or the board.
- Privilege. Where litigation is likely, an investigation commissioned through legal advisers may attract legal privilege. This must be structured from the outset.
- Evidence. Secure emails, devices and access logs lawfully, with regard to the Protection of Personal Information Act 4 of 2013 and the employer’s IT policies.
- Whistleblowers. If the allegations came from a whistleblower, or if the senior employee claims to be one, consider the Protected Disclosures Act 26 of 2000 and the risk of a referral to pre-dismissal arbitration under section 188A(11) of the LRA.
Running the disciplinary process
Choose the right forum
For senior employees, many employers appoint an external chairperson, often a senior advocate or labour law specialist, to ensure independence. Alternatively, with the employee’s consent, the employer can refer the allegations to pre-dismissal arbitration under section 188A, which produces a final and binding award and avoids a second hearing at the CCMA.
Charges and disclosure
Draft charges clearly, describe the misconduct accurately and give the employee enough information and time to prepare. Overcharging, or describing conduct in exaggerated terms, can undermine the employer’s case. In a 2026 Labour Court review involving social media misconduct, the court emphasised that conduct must be judged in context and described accurately.
Representation
Employees do not have an automatic right to legal representation in internal hearings, unless the disciplinary code provides for it. A chairperson may allow it, taking into account factors such as the complexity of the matter, the seriousness of the consequences and whether the employer is legally represented. For senior employees facing complex allegations, allowing representation often reduces the risk of a later procedural challenge.
Interdicts during the process
Senior employees sometimes approach the Labour Court to stop a disciplinary process. In a March 2026 judgment involving the Industrial Development Corporation, the Labour Appeal Court confirmed that courts should intervene in incomplete disciplinary processes only in exceptional circumstances, particularly where the employee will have remedies if dismissed.
Procedural fairness and its limits
A fair procedure remains important, because procedural unfairness can result in compensation. However, in a March 2026 judgment involving Universal Product Network, the Labour Appeal Court held that serious procedural flaws did not make a substantively fair dismissal unfair, and set aside an order of reinstatement. The lesson is that employers should follow a fair procedure, but the substance of the case is what determines whether a dismissal stands.
A checklist for senior employee discipline
- Assess the allegations and decide whether a precautionary suspension is justified.
- If so, suspend on full pay in writing, with reasons and a clear timeline.
- Appoint an independent investigator and structure the investigation for privilege where appropriate.
- Secure evidence lawfully and promptly.
- Consider whistleblower issues and the possibility of a section 188A(11) referral.
- Decide between an internal hearing with an external chair and pre-dismissal arbitration.
- Draft accurate charges and give proper disclosure.
- Decide on representation in advance.
- Plan communications to staff, clients, the board and, where relevant, regulators.
- Consider whether a negotiated exit is in the business’s interests at any stage.
How O’Reilly Law can help
We advise boards and employers on suspensions, investigations and disciplinary processes involving senior employees, draft charges, act as or brief independent chairpersons, conduct pre-dismissal arbitrations, oppose urgent applications to halt disciplinary processes and represent employers in the CCMA and Labour Court.
Contact us for advice on a senior employee disciplinary matter.
Related reading: CCTV, biometrics and employee monitoring under POPIA · Harassment in the workplace: employers’ duties
This article is general information and not legal advice. Correct as at November 2026.