When a marriage in community of property or with the accrual system ends in divorce, the default position is that the spouses share. In community of property, the joint estate is divided equally. Under the accrual system, the spouse whose estate grew less during the marriage has a claim to share in the other’s growth. For many people, that outcome feels fair.
Sometimes it does not. A spouse who contributed little, wasted assets or behaved very badly may still walk away with half of what the other built. Section 9 of the Divorce Act 70 of 1979 gives the court a way to prevent that: it can order that one spouse forfeits the patrimonial benefits of the marriage, in whole or in part.
Forfeiture claims are common, often hard-fought and frequently misunderstood. This article explains what can be forfeited, how courts decide, and what a recent High Court judgment shows about how the test is applied.
What section 9 says
When a court grants a divorce on the ground of irretrievable breakdown, it may order that one party forfeit the patrimonial benefits of the marriage, wholly or partly, if it is satisfied that the party will otherwise be unduly benefited. In deciding this, the court considers:
- the duration of the marriage;
- the circumstances that gave rise to the breakdown; and
- any substantial misconduct on the part of either party.
What can be forfeited, and what cannot
Forfeiture applies to the benefits a spouse gains because of the marriage, not to what that spouse brought in or earned themselves. In a marriage in community of property, the “benefit” is broadly the share of the joint estate that comes from the other spouse’s contributions. Under the accrual system, it is the accrual claim. Our courts have consistently held that a spouse cannot be made to forfeit their own contribution.
Because there is nothing to share, forfeiture has no real role in a marriage with complete separation of property and no accrual. For that regime, the relevant remedy is usually a redistribution claim under section 7(3), which the Constitutional Court extended in 2023 to such marriages regardless of when they were concluded.
Forfeiture can also be partial. A court may, for example, order forfeiture of a share in a particular asset, a business or a pension interest, while the rest of the estate is divided normally. A spouse’s pension interest is treated as part of their assets for divorce purposes under section 7(7) of the Act, so it can be the subject of a forfeiture order.
How courts apply the test
The courts follow a two-stage approach, confirmed by the Supreme Court of Appeal in cases such as Wijker v Wijker (1993) and Botha v Botha (2006):
- A factual question: would the spouse against whom forfeiture is sought receive a benefit if the estate were divided normally? This requires evidence of what each party contributed and what the estate consists of.
- A value judgment: would that benefit be undue, having regard to the three statutory factors?
The three factors do not all have to be present, and the court does not simply add them up. In Mashola v Mashola (2023), the Supreme Court of Appeal emphasised that courts must look at the whole picture, rather than fixing on a single incident of misconduct.
A recent example
In EM v SM [2026] ZAGPPHC 8, decided by the Gauteng Division of the High Court in January 2026, a spouse married in community of property sought forfeiture against the other. The court found that the other spouse’s misconduct, assessed as a whole, contributed to the breakdown and that an equal division would be an undue benefit. It treated the length of the marriage as neutral. The judgment also restates that contributions to the household and children count, even where a spouse earned less.
Importantly, the court did not order forfeiture of everything. It ordered partial forfeiture limited to a pension interest, and directed that the remaining joint assets be divided equally. Each party paid their own costs. The case illustrates how tailored forfeiture orders can be, and why the relief sought must be thought through carefully.
Practical points
- Plead it properly. Forfeiture must be specifically claimed in the pleadings, with the benefit and the grounds identified. Courts generally decide only what has been pleaded.
- Prove the benefit. You need evidence of the estate’s assets and liabilities and of each spouse’s contributions. Without it, the claim can fail at the first stage.
- Misconduct is not automatic. An affair or a breakdown of the relationship does not by itself justify forfeiture. The misconduct must be substantial and must make the benefit undue in all the circumstances.
- Non-financial contributions count. A spouse who managed the home and raised children has contributed to the marriage, which a court will weigh.
- Think about settlement. Forfeiture trials are expensive and emotionally draining. A credible forfeiture claim is often best used to negotiate a fair settlement.
- Costs are discretionary. Even a successful party may not recover their legal costs.
Steps if you are considering a forfeiture claim, or facing one
- Confirm your matrimonial property regime by checking for an antenuptial contract.
- Gather documents showing the assets and liabilities, including pension fund statements and business interests.
- Record each spouse’s contributions to the estate and the household, financial and otherwise.
- Write down the history of the breakdown and any misconduct, with dates and supporting evidence.
- Get advice on whether full or partial forfeiture is realistic, and which assets it should target.
- Make sure the claim, or the defence to it, is properly pleaded.
- Consider mediation or settlement before committing to a trial.
How O’Reilly Law can help
We act for spouses in contested and settled divorces, including forfeiture claims and defences. We assess whether a forfeiture claim is viable, help gather the financial evidence, draft and respond to pleadings, and negotiate settlement agreements that deal properly with the joint estate, accrual claims, pension interests and business assets. Where matters go to trial, we prepare and run the case with counsel.
Contact us for confidential advice on your divorce.
Related reading: Divorce in South Africa: a guide · Antenuptial contracts in South Africa
This article is general information and not legal advice. Correct as at November 2026.