Whistleblowers play an essential role in exposing fraud, corruption and safety failures. For large employers, a credible whistleblowing system is also a governance requirement and a source of early warning about problems that could otherwise surface as a regulatory investigation or a news story.
But whistleblowing also creates legal complexity. An employee who has made a disclosure and is then disciplined, transferred or dismissed may claim that the employer is retaliating. In some cases, the employee can move the disciplinary matter out of the employer’s hands and into pre-dismissal arbitration. In March 2026, the Labour Appeal Court clarified how this works in a case involving the Industrial Development Corporation, and in April 2026 the Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development released a draft Protected Disclosures Bill proposing a significant overhaul of the law.
The legal framework
The Protected Disclosures Act 26 of 2000 (PDA) protects employees, and since 2017 also workers such as independent contractors and consultants, who disclose information about criminal offences, breaches of legal obligations, miscarriages of justice, health and safety dangers, environmental damage, unfair discrimination or the concealment of any of these. To be protected, the disclosure must be made in the manner the PDA prescribes, for example to the employer under its procedures, to a legal adviser, to a prescribed regulator or, in limited circumstances, more generally.
Employers are required to have appropriate internal procedures for receiving and dealing with disclosures, and to take reasonable steps to bring them to employees’ attention.
The Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 (LRA) provides that:
- dismissing an employee because they made a protected disclosure is automatically unfair under section 187(1)(h), with compensation of up to 24 months’ remuneration;
- subjecting an employee to an occupational detriment on account of a protected disclosure is an unfair labour practice; and
- under section 188A(11), an employee who alleges that the disciplinary process itself is an occupational detriment caused by a protected disclosure may refer the matter to pre-dismissal arbitration instead of the internal hearing.
The Companies Act 71 of 2008 separately protects whistleblowers who disclose information about company-law contraventions, and requires public companies and state-owned companies to maintain a system for receiving disclosures confidentially.
Section 188A(11): what the Labour Appeal Court decided
In the March 2026 judgment, an employee facing a disciplinary enquiry invoked section 188A(11), and the Labour Court interdicted the employer’s internal process. The Labour Appeal Court set the interdict aside. It confirmed that:
- a referral under section 188A(11) is competent only if specific requirements are met: a disclosure that qualifies under the PDA, made in good faith, an occupational detriment, and a causal link between the two;
- it is for the CCMA, not the Labour Court, to decide whether those requirements are met; and
- courts should be slow to interrupt disciplinary processes before they are completed, particularly where the employee will have remedies if dismissed.
For employers, the judgment confirms that a bare claim of whistleblower status does not automatically halt a disciplinary process. An ordinary grievance or workplace complaint is not necessarily a protected disclosure, and the employer can test the claim before the CCMA.
The draft Protected Disclosures Bill, 2026
The draft Bill released on 10 April 2026 for public comment proposes, among other things, extending protection beyond the traditional employment relationship, strengthening protection against retaliation, prohibiting disclosure of a whistleblower’s identity without consent, making a breach of confidentiality a criminal offence, and introducing support for whistleblowers, possibly including awards and legal assistance. Comment closed on 14 May 2026. The Bill may change significantly before it is introduced in Parliament.
Managing the risk in practice
Separate the disclosure from the conduct
The most difficult cases arise where an employee who has made a disclosure is also facing allegations of misconduct or poor performance. The employer must be able to show that its action is based on the employee’s conduct or performance, and not on the disclosure. That requires contemporaneous evidence, consistency with how other employees have been treated, and decision-makers who are independent of the subject of the disclosure.
Investigate the disclosure properly
A disclosure should be assessed, investigated where appropriate and acted on. Failing to do so increases regulatory and reputational risk, and undermines the employer’s position if the whistleblower later alleges retaliation.
Protect confidentiality
Limit knowledge of the whistleblower’s identity to those who need it. Breaches of confidentiality are a common source of retaliation claims and, under the draft Bill, may become criminal offences.
A checklist for employers
- Review your whistleblowing policy against the PDA, the Companies Act and the draft Bill.
- Provide accessible, confidential reporting channels, including an independent hotline where appropriate.
- Train managers to recognise a potential protected disclosure and escalate it.
- Log every disclosure and record how it was investigated and resolved.
- Before disciplining an employee who has made a disclosure, obtain legal advice and document the independent basis for the action.
- Prepare to respond to a section 188A(11) referral, including a challenge to whether the jurisdictional requirements are met.
- Report to the board or audit and risk committee on disclosures and outcomes.
How O’Reilly Law can help
We draft and review whistleblowing policies and procedures, conduct and oversee independent investigations, advise on disciplinary action involving employees who have made disclosures, and represent employers in section 188A(11) proceedings, automatically unfair dismissal claims and related litigation.
Contact us for advice on whistleblowing and protected disclosures.
Related reading: Harassment in the workplace: employers’ duties · CCTV, biometrics and employee monitoring under POPIA
This article is general information and not legal advice. Correct as at November 2026.