Many commercial contracts contain a clause that fixes in advance what a party must pay if it breaches: a daily amount for late delivery, a set fee for early termination, or the forfeiture of a deposit if a buyer fails to pay. These clauses are attractive because they avoid the cost and uncertainty of proving damages after the event.
In South Africa, these clauses are governed by the Conventional Penalties Act 15 of 1962. The Act makes them enforceable, but it also gives courts the power to cut them down when they are out of proportion to the harm actually suffered. A clause that looks watertight on paper can be reduced, sometimes substantially, once a dispute reaches court.
The issue is a live one. In a judgment handed down by the Johannesburg High Court in November 2025, a seller of property was allowed to keep a purchaser’s deposit after the purchaser failed to deliver a bank guarantee in time. The court considered the purchaser’s request to reduce the forfeiture under the Act, but found that the seller’s actual losses exceeded the deposit. The case is a useful reminder that the outcome depends on the evidence of prejudice, not on how the clause is labelled.
What counts as a penalty clause?
The Act defines a penalty stipulation broadly. It covers any term under which a party that breaches the contract must pay money, deliver something or perform an obligation in favour of the other party. It does not matter whether the parties describe the amount as a penalty, a pre-estimate of damages, liquidated damages or a fee. If the obligation is triggered by a breach, the Act is likely to apply.
Common examples include:
- late delivery or completion penalties in supply and construction contracts, often calculated per day or per week;
- service credits in service level agreements, where they operate as a remedy for poor performance;
- early termination fees payable when a party cancels because of the other’s breach;
- penalty interest at a rate higher than the ordinary contractual rate, payable only on default; and
- forfeiture clauses, such as a clause allowing a seller to keep a deposit or instalments already paid if the buyer defaults.
Section 4 of the Act expressly extends the same rules to forfeiture clauses, so a deposit forfeiture is treated in the same way as a clause requiring a payment.
Penalty or damages: you usually cannot have both
Section 2(1) of the Act prevents a creditor from recovering both the penalty and damages for the same breach. It also prevents the creditor from claiming damages instead of the penalty, unless the contract expressly allows this.
This matters when drafting. If you want the option of claiming your full proven damages where they exceed the penalty, the contract must say so clearly. Without that wording, you may be limited to the penalty amount even if your real loss is much higher.
Section 2(2) adds a further rule. If a party accepts defective or late performance, it cannot later claim a penalty for that defect or delay unless the contract specifically provides for a penalty for that particular defect or delay. A general penalty clause may therefore not be enough to cover late or substandard performance that the creditor has accepted.
When a court can reduce a penalty
Section 3 is the heart of the Act. If a court finds that a penalty is out of proportion to the prejudice suffered by the creditor, it may reduce the penalty to the extent it considers fair. In assessing prejudice, the court looks not only at the creditor’s financial loss but at every other legitimate interest affected by the breach.
Several principles have emerged from the case law:
- The debtor must prove disproportion. The party seeking a reduction bears the onus of showing that the penalty is out of proportion to the creditor’s prejudice. Courts do not reduce penalties on their own initiative.
- Prejudice is assessed broadly. Lost profits, wasted costs, disruption, reputational harm and the loss of other opportunities can all count. In the November 2025 Johannesburg case, the seller’s collapsed onward purchase and a lost earlier offer were relevant.
- Reduction is not all or nothing. The court reduces the penalty to a fair amount. It does not strike the clause out entirely, unless the creditor suffered no prejudice at all.
- The threshold is meaningful. A penalty is not reduced simply because it is generous. It must be clearly disproportionate to the harm.
Other laws that limit penalties
The Conventional Penalties Act is not the only constraint. In consumer contracts, the Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008 allows a consumer to cancel a fixed-term agreement on notice, subject to a “reasonable cancellation penalty”, and its regulations set out factors that limit what a supplier may charge. The National Credit Act 34 of 2005 caps interest and fees in credit agreements, and restricts default charges. In sales of land on instalments, the Alienation of Land Act 68 of 1981 limits what a seller may keep when cancelling. Any penalty in these contexts must be checked against the specific statute as well.
Drafting penalty clauses that hold up
A penalty clause is most likely to be enforced in full if it is tied to a genuine commercial interest and can be justified with evidence later. Practical steps include:
- Identify the specific breach the clause addresses, such as late delivery, a missed milestone or failure to pay a deposit.
- Calibrate the amount to the likely loss. Keep a short internal note of how the figure was arrived at, as this helps if the amount is challenged.
- Consider a cap, for example a maximum of a percentage of the contract price, so that a per-day penalty does not run indefinitely.
- State clearly whether the creditor may claim damages instead of the penalty where its proven loss is higher.
- Where you want a penalty for late or defective performance that you may still accept, say so expressly to avoid the section 2(2) problem.
- Align the clause with any limitation of liability provisions, so that one does not cancel out the other.
- Check whether consumer, credit or land legislation applies, and adjust the clause accordingly.
- When enforcing, gather evidence of your actual prejudice early. You may need it if the debtor asks the court for a reduction.
If a penalty is claimed against you
If you are on the receiving end of a penalty claim, first check whether the clause applies to the breach alleged and whether the other party has accepted late or defective performance. Then consider whether the penalty is out of proportion to the real harm. Because you bear the onus, you will need facts that show the creditor’s prejudice is much smaller than the amount claimed. A reduction application can be raised as a defence in the same proceedings.
How O’Reilly Law can help
We draft and review commercial contracts, including supply, service, construction and sale agreements, with penalty, service credit and forfeiture clauses designed to be enforceable. We advise on claims for penalties and on applications to reduce them, and we assist with negotiation and litigation when disputes arise.
Need a penalty clause drafted or reviewed? Contact us to discuss your contract.
Related reading: Limitation of liability and indemnity clauses: what do they really protect? · Service level agreements: how to make service commitments enforceable
This article is general information and not legal advice. Correct as at November 2026.