Received a PAIA request? How to respond

A letter arrives addressed to your information officer. A former employee, a shareholder, a competitor, a journalist or an advocacy group wants copies of your records under the Promotion of Access to Information Act. The clock is already running.

Many private businesses treat these requests as unusual or hostile, and respond late, informally or not at all. That approach is increasingly risky. The Information Regulator now has power to investigate complaints about PAIA requests and to issue enforcement notices, and it has shown in 2026 that it expects refusals to be properly justified.

This article explains how PAIA applies to private bodies, the steps and time limits for responding, the grounds on which you may refuse, and what recent enforcement tells us.

Does PAIA apply to your business?

The Promotion of Access to Information Act 2 of 2000 (PAIA) gives effect to the constitutional right of access to information. It applies to public bodies and to private bodies. A private body includes a company, a close corporation, a partnership and a sole proprietor acting in a business capacity.

Under section 50, a requester is entitled to a record held by a private body if:

  • the record is required for the exercise or protection of a right;
  • the requester complies with the procedural requirements of PAIA; and
  • no ground of refusal in the Act applies.

The courts have held that “required” sets a meaningful threshold. In Clutchco (Pty) Ltd v Davis 2005 (3) SA 486 (SCA), the Supreme Court of Appeal indicated that the requester must show more than that the record would be useful. There must be a substantial advantage or an element of need. A vague reference to constitutional rights is not enough.

Step 1: check that the request is valid

A valid request to a private body must be made on the prescribed form and addressed to the head of the private body, in practice the information officer or a deputy information officer. The requester must identify the records sought, identify the right they want to exercise or protect, and explain why the record is required for that purpose.

If a request is sent to the wrong person, for example to HR or a branch manager, it should be passed to the information officer promptly. If the form or content is deficient, tell the requester what is missing. Simply ignoring a defective request can backfire if the Regulator later considers that you should have helped the requester to comply.

The requester may be required to pay a request fee and, if access is granted, an access fee for search, preparation and reproduction. The fees are set in the PAIA regulations.

Step 2: diarise the deadlines

A private body must decide on a request and notify the requester within 30 days of receiving it (section 56). That period may be extended once, by no more than a further 30 days, in limited circumstances such as a large volume of records or the need to consult others (section 57). The requester must be told of the extension and the reasons for it.

If you do not respond within the time allowed, the request is deemed to have been refused (section 58). The requester can then complain to the Information Regulator or go to court.

Step 3: notify affected third parties

If the records contain personal information about other people, or commercial or confidential information of a third party, PAIA requires you to take reasonable steps to inform that third party and give them an opportunity to make representations before you decide. Third-party notification is a mandatory step, not a courtesy. Failing to notify can undermine your decision.

Step 4: consider the grounds of refusal

Chapter 4 of Part 3 of PAIA sets out the grounds on which a private body may or must refuse access. The main grounds include:

  • Unreasonable disclosure of personal information about a third party who is a natural person (section 63);
  • Third parties’ commercial information, such as trade secrets or information whose disclosure would likely harm their commercial or financial interests (section 64);
  • Confidential information of a third party, where disclosure would breach a duty of confidence owed under an agreement (section 65);
  • Safety of individuals and protection of property (section 66);
  • Legal privilege, unless the privilege has been waived (section 67);
  • Your own commercial information, including trade secrets and information whose disclosure would likely cause harm to your commercial or financial interests (section 68); and
  • Research information (section 69).

Some grounds are mandatory and some are discretionary. Even where a ground applies, section 70 requires disclosure if it would reveal evidence of a substantial contravention of the law or an imminent and serious risk to public safety or the environment, and the public interest clearly outweighs the harm.

Where only part of a record is protected, you must disclose the remainder (severability). Refusing the entire record because one page is sensitive is not compliant.

What recent enforcement shows

Two 2026 decisions of the Information Regulator illustrate the approach.

In January 2026 the Regulator issued an enforcement notice against the JSE following a request for trading and settlement records. It rejected arguments based on personal information, third-party commercial harm and contractual confidentiality. The Regulator found that the claimed harm was speculative, that a confidentiality clause cannot override PAIA, and that the JSE had not notified affected third parties.

In May 2026 the Regulator directed Sibanye-Stillwater to provide annual compliance reports on its social and labour plans to a research centre. The Regulator accepted that the reports contained commercial information, but found that the company had not shown that disclosure would likely cause the harm it claimed. Concerns about reputation and misinterpretation were not enough.

The lesson is simple. Naming a section of PAIA is not a refusal. You need specific facts, and preferably evidence, showing why the ground applies to the particular record.

Step 5: give a proper written decision

If you grant access, state the access fee and the form of access. If you refuse, in whole or in part, your notice must give adequate reasons, identify the provisions relied on, and inform the requester that they may lodge a complaint with the Information Regulator or apply to court. Keep a record of the request, your correspondence and your reasons.

What happens next

A requester who is unhappy with your decision may complain to the Information Regulator, generally within 180 days. The Regulator can investigate, attempt to settle the matter and issue an enforcement notice. Failing to comply with an enforcement notice is an offence. A requester may also apply to court once the complaint procedure has been used.

Checklist: responding to a PAIA request

  1. Record the date of receipt and diarise the 30-day deadline.
  2. Pass the request to the information officer and confirm it is on the prescribed form.
  3. Check whether the requester has identified a right and why the records are required.
  4. Locate and preserve the requested records.
  5. Identify and notify any affected third parties.
  6. Assess each record against the grounds of refusal, and consider the public interest override.
  7. Prepare evidence supporting any refusal, and sever protected parts rather than refusing whole records.
  8. Decide whether a 30-day extension is genuinely needed, and give written notice of it in time.
  9. Issue a written decision with reasons and notice of the requester’s remedies.
  10. Keep a file, and update your PAIA manual if the request exposes gaps.

How O’Reilly Law can help

We assist private bodies to respond to PAIA requests, from assessing whether a request is valid to preparing reasoned decisions, third-party notices and responses to Information Regulator complaints and enforcement proceedings. We also prepare and update PAIA manuals and advise information officers on their duties under PAIA and the Protection of Personal Information Act.

Received a PAIA request? Contact us for help with your response.

Related reading: Information officers under POPIA and PAIA: duties and registration · Data breaches under POPIA: what business owners must do

This article is general information and not legal advice. Correct as at November 2026.