Cannabis, alcohol and drug testing at work: what employers can and cannot do

Substance use is one of the most common sources of workplace discipline, and one of the most frequently mishandled. Alcohol has always posed challenges. Cannabis has added a new layer, because adults may now lawfully use it in private, yet a drug test can show a positive result for days or weeks after use.

The Labour Appeal Court’s April 2024 decision in a case against Barloworld Equipment made the risk clear. An office-based employee who used cannabis at home, and who was never shown to be impaired at work, was dismissed under a zero-tolerance policy after testing positive. The court found the dismissal automatically unfair, held that the policy unfairly discriminated against her as applied to her role, and awarded 24 months’ compensation.

The Cannabis for Private Purposes Act 7 of 2024 was signed in 2024, and draft regulations setting possession and cultivation limits were published for comment in early 2026. Employers who still rely on an old “any trace means dismissal” policy should review it now.

What the law allows, and what it does not

The Constitutional Court decriminalised private adult use, possession and cultivation of cannabis in 2018, and the 2024 Act gives effect to that decision. Neither the judgment nor the Act gives anyone a right to be under the influence at work. The right protected is a right to privacy in private spaces.

Employers remain bound by the Occupational Health and Safety Act 85 of 1993 (OHS Act), which requires them to provide a safe working environment so far as reasonably practicable. The General Safety Regulations under the OHS Act prohibit employers from allowing a person who is, or appears to be, under the influence of intoxicating liquor or drugs to enter or remain at the workplace. That duty applies equally to alcohol, cannabis, other drugs and misused medication.

Impairment, not presence, is the real question

The key lesson from the Barloworld case is that a positive test is not the same as impairment. Breathalyser readings for alcohol correlate reasonably well with intoxication at the time of testing. Common cannabis tests detect THC, or its by-products, long after any effect has worn off. A positive result may therefore say very little about whether the employee was fit for work that day.

The court was careful to limit its findings to the facts. The employee worked in an office, did not operate machinery and posed no safety risk. The court indicated that the position could be different for employees in safety-sensitive roles, such as drivers, machine operators, miners and those working at heights. In those jobs, a stricter approach, including a zero-tolerance rule for being at work with substances in the system, may be justified, provided the policy is rational and consistently applied.

Misconduct or incapacity?

An employer must first decide what kind of problem it is dealing with. The Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 (LRA) and the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal treat misconduct and incapacity differently.

  • Misconduct applies where an employee breaks a known rule, for example arriving at work under the influence, using substances on duty, or refusing a lawful test. The employer must follow a fair disciplinary process and impose a sanction that fits the offence.
  • Incapacity applies where the employee is dependent on alcohol or drugs. Courts have long accepted that dependence is an illness. The employer’s focus must be on counselling, treatment and rehabilitation, and dismissal is a last resort after these have been tried.

In 2025 the Labour Court, in a matter involving a provincial department, set aside the dismissal of an employee whose absences were linked to alcohol dependence. The employer had treated the case as misconduct. The court found that it should have been handled as incapacity and ordered reinstatement. Mislabelling the problem can make an otherwise justified dismissal unfair.

Drug testing and privacy

Testing is lawful if it is provided for in a clear policy, is reasonable, and is carried out fairly. The Employment Equity Act 55 of 1998 restricts medical testing of employees, and the Protection of Personal Information Act 4 of 2013 (POPIA) treats health information as special personal information. Test results must be handled confidentially, accessed only by those who need them, and kept only as long as necessary.

Good practice includes using accredited testing methods, allowing the employee to give an explanation (including any prescribed medication), and offering a confirmatory laboratory test where a screening test is positive.

Building a defensible substance policy

  1. Classify roles by risk. Identify safety-sensitive positions where a stricter standard is justified, and explain why.
  2. Prohibit being under the influence of alcohol or drugs at work for everyone, and prohibit possession or use of substances on the premises or while on duty.
  3. Set out when testing will happen, such as pre-employment, on reasonable suspicion, after incidents, and at random for safety-sensitive roles.
  4. Focus on fitness for work. For non-safety-sensitive roles, rely on observable signs of impairment and on performance, not only on a positive test.
  5. Describe the testing process, the right to a confirmatory test, and how results will be stored under POPIA.
  6. Encourage employees to disclose dependence, and provide access to an employee assistance programme or treatment.
  7. Distinguish clearly between disciplinary steps for misconduct and an incapacity process for dependence.
  8. Deal with medical cannabis and prescribed medication, including a duty to report medication that may affect safe work.
  9. Train managers to recognise impairment and to document what they observe.
  10. Consult employees or unions, communicate the policy clearly, and apply it consistently.

How O’Reilly Law can help

We draft and review substance abuse and drug testing policies, tailored to the risk profile of different roles. We advise employers on disciplinary and incapacity processes, chair or prepare for enquiries, and represent employers at the CCMA and in the Labour Court.

Is your substance policy up to date? Contact us for a review.

Related reading: Health and safety duties of employers and directors under the OHS Act · CCTV, biometrics and employee monitoring: staying POPIA-compliant

This article is general information and not legal advice. Correct as at November 2026.