Being arrested or charged does not always have to end in a trial and a criminal record. For many first-time and less serious offences, prosecutors can divert the matter out of the formal court process. If the accused person completes an agreed programme or meets certain conditions, the charges are withdrawn and no conviction follows.
Diversion is one of the most valuable outcomes available in a criminal case, especially for people whose careers, travel plans or professional registrations would be affected by a record. Yet many people do not know it exists, or only learn about it after they have paid an admission of guilt fine, which does result in a criminal record.
The law in this area is also developing. In February 2025, the South African Law Reform Commission published a discussion paper recommending that adult diversion be placed on a proper legislative footing, similar to the system that already exists for children. For children, the Department of Justice issued a new procedural directive under the Child Justice Act in 2026 to standardise how diversion is referred and monitored.
What is diversion?
Diversion means steering a criminal matter away from prosecution and trial, usually on conditions. Typical conditions include attending a life skills, anger management, substance abuse or similar programme, performing community service, making an apology, or compensating the victim. Programmes are run by organisations such as NICRO and Khulisa, and by the Department of Social Development, often at no cost to the accused.
Once the conditions are met, the prosecutor withdraws the charges. Because there has been no conviction, the person does not receive a criminal record for that offence.
Adults: diversion at the prosecutor’s discretion
There is currently no statute that governs diversion for adults. It operates through the prosecutor’s power to withdraw charges and the National Prosecuting Authority’s prosecution policy directives, which set out when diversion may be considered. The decision lies entirely with the prosecutor. An accused person cannot demand it, but they or their lawyer can ask for it and make representations.
In practice, prosecutors usually consider:
- whether the offence is minor or less serious, such as petty theft, shoplifting, common assault, malicious damage to property or possession of small quantities of drugs;
- whether the accused is a first offender or has a limited history;
- whether there is a prima facie case, meaning enough evidence to prosecute;
- whether the accused acknowledges responsibility for the conduct;
- the views of the victim, and whether harm can be repaired; and
- the public interest, including whether diversion is appropriate for the type of offence.
Serious violent and sexual offences are generally not suitable for diversion. The SALRC’s proposals would introduce schedules of eligible offences, require recorded reasons for diversion decisions and improve record keeping, which should make the system more consistent if enacted.
Children: diversion under the Child Justice Act
For children in conflict with the law, diversion is regulated in detail by the Child Justice Act 75 of 2008. The Act requires a probation officer to assess the child, and allows diversion either by the prosecutor for minor offences or at a preliminary inquiry for more serious ones. The child must acknowledge responsibility without undue influence, there must be a prima facie case, and the child and, where available, a parent or guardian must consent.
If the child complies with the diversion order, they cannot be prosecuted on the same facts. The Act places strong emphasis on restorative justice and on avoiding the stigma of a criminal record.
Diversion compared with an admission of guilt fine
Many people charged with minor offences are offered the option of paying an admission of guilt fine under the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977. It can seem like the easiest way to make the matter go away. However, paying an admission of guilt fine is treated as a conviction and sentence, and it generally results in a criminal record.
Before paying, it is worth getting advice on whether diversion, or a withdrawal of the charge on other grounds, is a realistic alternative.
Diversion for companies
A related development applies to companies. In 2024 the National Prosecuting Authority adopted a corporate alternative dispute resolution policy, under which a company that self-reports wrongdoing, cooperates, pays restitution and improves its compliance programme may avoid prosecution. It does not protect individual employees or directors, who can still be prosecuted.
How to ask for diversion
- Get legal advice as early as possible, ideally before the first court appearance and before paying any admission of guilt fine.
- Do not make statements to the police about the offence without advice.
- Gather documents that support your request, such as proof of employment or studies, character references and confirmation that you have no previous convictions.
- Have your lawyer make written representations to the prosecutor, explaining why diversion is appropriate.
- Where there is a victim, consider whether an apology or compensation is possible.
- If diversion is offered, read the conditions carefully and make sure you can meet them.
- Complete the programme in full and keep proof of completion. Failing to comply allows the prosecution to continue.
- Confirm that the charge has been formally withdrawn, and check your criminal record status afterwards.
How O’Reilly Law can help
We represent clients facing criminal charges, from the first appearance through to trial. We prepare representations to prosecutors for diversion or withdrawal of charges, advise on admission of guilt fines, and assist with expungement of old records. We also advise companies on corporate criminal exposure and on the NPA’s corporate resolution process.
Facing a criminal charge? Contact us before your first court date.
Related reading: Criminal records and expungement: how to clear your record · Charged with drunk driving? What happens next
This article is general information and not legal advice. Correct as at November 2026.