Few documents are as alarming for a business owner as a winding-up application. A creditor, sometimes a supplier the company has been arguing with for months, asks the High Court to place the company in liquidation. If the court grants a provisional order, the directors lose control of the business immediately, a liquidator takes over, bank accounts are frozen and staff, customers and funders quickly hear about it.
Liquidation proceedings are also a well-known pressure tactic. Some creditors use them to force payment of a debt that is genuinely in dispute. The courts have long said that this is an abuse, and a company that responds quickly and properly can often have the application dismissed.
A judgment of the Gauteng Division of the High Court, Pretoria, reported in May 2026, is a useful reminder. A plant hire supplier applied to wind up a civil engineering company for an alleged debt of more than R800 000, relying on invoices and a certificate of balance. The company’s director denied signing or authorising the agreement, and argued that its terms were too uncertain to enforce. The court dismissed the application, holding that a genuine dispute about whether the contract was valid had to be resolved by action, not by liquidation.
The legal framework
The winding-up of insolvent companies is still governed largely by Chapter 14 of the Companies Act 61 of 1973, which continues to apply under the transitional provisions of the Companies Act 71 of 2008. Solvent companies are wound up under sections 79 to 81 of the 2008 Act.
A creditor usually applies on the basis that the company is unable to pay its debts. Section 345 of the 1973 Act deems a company unable to pay its debts if, among other things:
- a creditor owed R100 or more that is due has served a written demand at the registered office, and the company has not paid, secured or compounded the debt to the creditor’s reasonable satisfaction within three weeks;
- a warrant of execution has been returned by the sheriff with a return that there were no assets to satisfy the judgment; or
- it is otherwise proved that the company cannot pay its debts as they fall due.
The test is commercial insolvency: whether the company can pay its debts as they become due in the ordinary course of business. A company can have assets that exceed its liabilities and still be commercially insolvent. Courts may also wind up a company where it is just and equitable to do so.
The main defences
1. The debt is disputed on bona fide and reasonable grounds
This is the most important defence. Under what is known as the Badenhorst rule, winding-up proceedings are not a legitimate way to enforce a debt that the company genuinely disputes on reasonable grounds. If the dispute is real, the application should be dismissed and the creditor left to sue in the ordinary way.
The company does not have to prove its defence at this stage. It must show, with facts and documents, that the dispute is genuine and that its version is not far-fetched. Bare denials are not enough. Typical grounds include that goods were defective, services were not rendered, the amount is wrong, the contract was not concluded or authorised, or the creditor owes the company more under a counterclaim.
2. The company is not insolvent
Where the debt itself is not disputed, the company may show that it can pay its debts as they fall due. Management accounts, bank statements, cash-flow forecasts and confirmation from auditors can all help. Paying or securing the debt before the hearing is often the simplest answer, although the court retains a discretion.
3. Procedural defects
The Act and the court rules impose strict requirements. Section 346(4A) requires the applicant to furnish a copy of the application to the company’s employees and any registered trade union, to SARS and to the company itself. The section 345 demand must be properly delivered to the registered office. Defects can lead to a postponement or dismissal.
4. Abuse of process
If the creditor is using the application to pressure the company into paying a disputed amount, or for an ulterior purpose, the court can dismiss it and may order punitive costs.
5. Business rescue
If the company is financially distressed but has a reasonable prospect of rescue, the board can resolve to begin business rescue under section 129 of the 2008 Act, or an affected person can apply to court under section 131. Under section 131(6), an application for business rescue suspends pending liquidation proceedings until the court decides it. This must be a genuine rescue attempt. Courts look closely at last-minute applications that appear designed only to delay.
What to do if you are served
- Do not ignore it. Note the date for filing a notice of intention to oppose and the hearing date. Applications for a provisional order can be heard quickly.
- Get legal advice immediately and send your lawyer the application, the contract, correspondence and any letter of demand.
- Decide whether the debt is genuinely disputed, admitted, or partly admitted.
- If disputed, gather the evidence: the contract, delivery notes, complaints, emails, expert reports and records of any counterclaim.
- If admitted, consider paying, securing or settling the debt, or agreeing a payment arrangement in writing.
- Prepare evidence of solvency where that is in issue.
- Check whether the applicant has complied with the service and procedural requirements.
- If the company is in real distress, consider business rescue promptly and with proper advice, not as a delaying tactic.
- Deliver a full answering affidavit on time. The court decides these matters largely on the papers.
- If a provisional order has already been granted, act before the return date, when the company can argue that the order should be discharged.
For creditors: use the right tool
Creditors should take note too. Bringing a winding-up application on a debt the creditor knows is disputed can result in dismissal and an adverse costs order. Where the debt is genuinely contested, issuing summons and obtaining judgment is often faster in the end.
How O’Reilly Law can help
We act for companies opposing winding-up applications and for creditors seeking to recover debts, including through action proceedings, statutory demands and liquidation where appropriate. We also advise directors on their duties when a company is financially distressed, and on whether business rescue or a negotiated arrangement with creditors is the better route.
Served with a liquidation application? Contact us immediately so we can assess your defences.
Related reading: Prescription: when does your claim or debt expire? · You won your case: how to enforce a judgment in South Africa
This article is general information and not legal advice. Correct as at November 2026.