Employee share schemes are often associated with start-ups and listed companies. In practice, many established private companies use them too: to keep senior managers, to reward long-serving staff, to plan succession or to meet empowerment objectives. When they work, employees think and act like owners. When they are poorly designed, they create tax surprises, disputes when people leave and shareholders the company never intended to have.
The rules are spread across the Companies Act, the Income Tax Act, labour law and, for listed companies, the JSE Listings Requirements. SARS continues to issue rulings in this area. In August 2026, for example, it published Binding Private Ruling 429 on cash contributions made by a group of companies to an employee incentive trust that buys shares and awards them to senior managers on vesting.
This article sets out the main structuring choices and the legal and tax points that established companies should consider.
Common structures
Most schemes fall into one of a few categories:
- Share options: employees receive the right to buy shares at a fixed price in the future.
- Forfeitable or restricted share awards: employees receive shares, or the right to shares, which vest after a period of service or the achievement of performance targets, and are forfeited if they leave early.
- Share purchase schemes with funding: employees buy shares, often funded by a loan from the company or a trust, repaid from dividends.
- Employee share trusts: a trust holds shares for the benefit of employees, and either allocates shares to individuals on vesting or distributes dividends to participants.
- Broad-based schemes: shares are offered to most employees on similar terms, often for little or no consideration.
Where the business wants the economic benefit without issuing equity, a cash-settled phantom scheme may be more suitable. We discuss those in a separate article.
Companies Act requirements
The Companies Act 71 of 2008 defines an “employee share scheme” and, in section 97, sets out requirements for schemes that want certain benefits under the Act. These include appointing a compliance officer, who must administer the scheme and report annually in the company’s financial statements on matters such as the number of shares allocated and the participants.
A scheme that meets section 97 is relieved from some of the Act’s general requirements. In particular, the special resolution normally required to issue shares to directors, prescribed officers and related persons, and the restrictions on financial assistance for the acquisition of shares, are relaxed for qualifying schemes. An offer made under a qualifying scheme is also generally excluded from the rules on offers to the public.
Even where a scheme qualifies, the company’s memorandum of incorporation and any shareholders’ agreement must permit the share issue, and pre-emptive rights of existing shareholders may need to be waived. These documents should be checked before the scheme is launched, not after.
The tax position for employees
The key provision is section 8C of the Income Tax Act 58 of 1962. Where an employee or director acquires an equity instrument because of their employment, any gain is generally taxed as income, not as a capital gain, when the instrument vests. Vesting typically occurs once restrictions fall away, for example when the employee is free to sell the shares. The employer must deduct employees’ tax at that point.
This has practical consequences:
- the employee may owe tax on a large gain without having received cash, unless the scheme provides for the sale of some shares or a cash payment to cover the tax;
- growth after vesting is generally subject to capital gains tax when the shares are later sold; and
- dividends received on restricted instruments before vesting can, in certain circumstances, be taxed as income rather than being exempt, depending on how the scheme is structured.
Section 8B provides more favourable treatment for qualifying broad-based employee share plans. Among other requirements, at least 80% of permanent employees who have been employed full-time for at least a year must be entitled to participate, and the market value of shares an employee receives under the plan must not exceed R50,000 over the current and previous four years of assessment. Gains on shares disposed of within five years are taxed as income, but after five years they are generally subject to capital gains tax. The employer may claim a deduction under section 11(lA), limited to R10,000 per employee per year.
The tax position for the company and the trust
Where a company funds a trust to acquire shares for employees, questions arise about whether the company can deduct the cost, how the trust is taxed and when capital gains are triggered. These depend heavily on the facts. BPR 429 illustrates the kind of structure SARS has accepted, including a deduction for the contributing group companies (subject to the rules on prepaid expenditure) and the timing of the trust’s disposal of the shares on vesting. A binding private ruling applies only to the applicants, but it shows how SARS approaches similar arrangements. Professional tax advice is essential before implementing or changing a trust-based scheme.
Leavers, valuations and disputes
The scheme rules must deal clearly with what happens when a participant leaves. Most schemes distinguish between good leavers (for example retirement, death, disability or retrenchment) and bad leavers (for example resignation or dismissal for misconduct), with different consequences for unvested awards and the price at which vested shares may be bought back.
In a private company, there is no market price. The scheme should set out a clear valuation method, who performs the valuation and how disputes are resolved. Disputes about scheme benefits can also have a labour law dimension, so the interaction between the scheme rules, employment contracts and company policies must be consistent.
Checklist for designing a scheme
- Define the purpose: retention, reward, succession, empowerment or a combination.
- Decide who participates and whether the scheme is selective or broad-based.
- Choose the structure: options, restricted shares, a share trust or a cash-settled alternative.
- Check the MOI and shareholders’ agreement, and obtain shareholder approvals and waivers.
- Decide whether to meet the section 97 requirements and appoint a compliance officer.
- Model the tax impact for participants, the company and any trust, including PAYE at vesting.
- Set vesting conditions, good and bad leaver rules and a clear valuation method.
- Plan how participants will fund the purchase price and tax.
- Prepare clear scheme rules and participant communications.
- Review the scheme regularly, especially after a restructure, capital raise or change in tax law.
How O’Reilly Law can help
We design and document employee share schemes and share incentive trusts for established private companies, including scheme rules, trust deeds, award letters, shareholder resolutions and amendments to MOIs and shareholders’ agreements. We work with clients’ tax advisers on the tax structure, and advise on leaver provisions, valuations and disputes under existing schemes.
Considering an employee share scheme? Contact us to discuss the right structure.
Related reading: Phantom shares and cash-settled incentive schemes · Retention bonuses and clawback clauses
This article is general information and not legal or tax advice. Correct as at November 2026.