Managing strikes and pickets: protected, unprotected and violent industrial action

For large employers with unionised workforces, industrial action is a recurring business risk. A well-prepared employer can keep operating safely through a protected strike and respond firmly to unprotected action or violence. An unprepared one can find itself making concessions under pressure, or facing litigation over dismissals, interdicts and damages.

Two Constitutional Court judgments shape how employers should respond when a strike turns unlawful. In 2022, in a dispute involving Oak Valley Farm, the Court held that interdicts may not be granted against striking workers as a group simply because some of them acted unlawfully. In March 2026, in South African Commercial Catering and Allied Workers Union v Massmart Holdings Ltd [2026] ZACC 11, the Court held that the Labour Court cannot award compensation under section 68 of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 (LRA) for misconduct during a protected strike. Such losses must be claimed in the High Court under ordinary legal principles.

Protected and unprotected strikes

The right to strike is guaranteed by section 23 of the Constitution and regulated by the LRA. A strike is protected if it complies with section 64, which generally requires that:

  • the dispute was referred to the CCMA or a bargaining council for conciliation;
  • a certificate of non-resolution was issued, or 30 days (or an agreed extension) have passed since the referral; and
  • the employer was given at least 48 hours’ written notice of the start of the strike (seven days where the employer is the state).

A strike is not protected if, among other things, it concerns an issue that a collective agreement prohibits striking over, an issue that must be referred to arbitration or the Labour Court, or employees engaged in an essential service.

What employers may and may not do during a protected strike

  • No work, no pay. Under section 67(3), the employer is not obliged to pay employees for services they do not render during a protected strike. Where payment in kind, such as accommodation or food, forms part of remuneration, special rules apply.
  • No dismissal for striking. Dismissing an employee for participating in a protected strike is automatically unfair. However, employees may still be disciplined or dismissed for misconduct committed during the strike, and the employer’s operational requirements remain a potential ground for dismissal in appropriate circumstances.
  • Replacement labour. Section 76 generally permits an employer to use replacement labour during a protected strike, except where the work affected is a maintenance service. Replacement labour may not be used during an offensive lock-out.
  • No civil liability for the strike itself. Participants in a protected strike are not liable in contract or delict for the strike itself. That immunity does not extend to criminal conduct.

Picketing rules

Peaceful picketing in support of a protected strike is protected by section 69. Since the 2018 amendments to the LRA, the CCMA or bargaining council must try to secure agreement on picketing rules when a strike dispute is referred, and can determine rules if the parties cannot agree, so rules should be in place before a protected strike begins. Picketing rules typically regulate where picketers may gather, numbers, conduct, access to premises and the role of marshals. Employers should prioritise securing clear picketing rules, because breaches of those rules are the most common basis for later enforcement steps.

Responding to unprotected action and violence

Interdicts

Under section 68(1), the Labour Court may interdict an unprotected strike or conduct in contemplation or furtherance of one. Interdicts may also be sought to enforce picketing rules or to restrain unlawful conduct. Following the Oak Valley judgment, employers should identify the individuals involved and present evidence linking each respondent to the unlawful conduct, rather than seeking an order against all strikers. Video footage, security logs and witness statements collected during the strike are critical.

Ultimatums and dismissal

Participation in an unprotected strike is misconduct, but dismissal is not automatic. The fairness of a dismissal depends on factors such as the seriousness of the breach, attempts to comply with the LRA and whether the strike was a response to unjustified conduct by the employer. Before dismissing, employers should generally engage the union, issue a clear ultimatum giving employees a reasonable time to reflect and return to work, and give employees an opportunity to make representations.

Damages after the Massmart judgment

Section 68(1)(b) allows the Labour Court to order just and equitable compensation for losses caused by an unprotected strike. In the Massmart case, the employer sought compensation from the union for losses allegedly caused by breaches of picketing rules during a protected national strike. The Constitutional Court held that the section 68 compensation remedy is available only for unprotected action. Losses caused by unlawful conduct during a protected strike must be pursued as an ordinary delictual claim in the High Court, which is generally slower and more demanding to prove. The employer’s right to discipline employees for misconduct during a protected strike is unaffected.

Preparing for wage negotiations

  1. Map your collective agreements, bargaining council obligations and the issues on which strikes are prohibited.
  2. Agree picketing rules early, ideally before negotiations reach deadlock.
  3. Prepare a contingency plan covering operations, replacement labour, security and customer communications.
  4. Train managers on lawful conduct during a strike, including what they may say to employees.
  5. Set up evidence gathering: cameras, incident logs and named witnesses at each site.
  6. Prepare draft interdict papers that can be adapted quickly to the facts.
  7. Plan for the end of the strike, including return-to-work agreements and the handling of misconduct cases.
  8. Consider whether the dispute is suitable for advisory arbitration or facilitated settlement.

How O’Reilly Law can help

We advise employers on wage negotiations and strike contingency planning, negotiate and enforce picketing rules, bring urgent interdicts in the Labour Court, advise on ultimatums and dismissals for unprotected action, handle post-strike disciplinary processes, and pursue damages claims where losses are caused by unlawful conduct.

Contact us to prepare for, or respond to, industrial action.

Related reading: Urgent interdicts in South Africa · Retrenchments: getting the section 189 process right

This article is general information and not legal advice. Correct as at November 2026.